Broken links and out-of-stock products
Do broken links hurt SEO? What affiliate sites should know
Broken links get blamed for ranking drops all the time. The truth is more useful. Some broken links barely matter to Google, while others quietly cost affiliate sites far more in commissions than in rankings.
The short answer
- Broken links are not a ranking penalty. Google treats 404 pages as a normal part of the web.
- They are a quality signal. Google's Search Quality Rater Guidelines treat signs of an unmaintained site, broken links among them, as a mark of low quality, especially when the page no longer serves its purpose.
- On affiliate sites the bigger cost is money. A dead or untagged Amazon link earns nothing, whatever it does to rankings.
Three kinds of broken link, three different costs
| Type | Example | SEO effect | Money effect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Internal | Your guide links to /best-kettles/, which you deleted | Wastes crawl paths and link value; frustrates readers | Readers leave instead of reaching your money page |
| Outbound | A source you cite moved | Small; mostly a reader-trust issue | Little |
| Affiliate | Amazon product removed, out of stock, or untagged | Crawlers usually can't see it | Every click through it is wasted |
Internal broken links
These matter most for SEO. Internal links tell Google which pages are important and help it find new ones. When they point at 404s, that value is wasted and readers hit dead ends. Fix them by updating the link or adding a redirect to the closest live page.
Outbound broken links
Linking to a page that has since moved is normal on an old site. It doesn't trigger a penalty, but a guide full of dead sources looks neglected to readers and to quality reviewers. Fix them when you update the page.
Affiliate links: the invisible kind
Most affiliate links don't return a 404 when they fail:
- an out-of-stock Amazon product page loads normally;
- a link with a missing tag works perfectly, it just doesn't pay you;
- an amzn.to short link redirects somewhere, even if that somewhere is useless.
That's why ordinary SEO crawlers report a clean bill of health on sites that are losing a big share of their commissions. Finding these needs a check of the tag in each link and of the product's status at Amazon. See how to find broken Amazon affiliate links.
What Google has actually said
- 404s are normal. Google's documentation on HTTP status codes says URLs that return a 404 are removed from the index, and Google has long said that 404s on their own don't hurt the rest of a site's ranking.
- Maintenance is part of quality. The Search Quality Rater Guidelines, used by people who evaluate Google's results, describe unmaintained websites that fail their purpose as low quality. A "best products" page whose top picks can't be bought is a page failing its purpose.
- Mark paid links. Google asks sites to add
rel="sponsored"to affiliate links. It's not about broken links, but it's the other link rule every affiliate site should follow. More on rel="sponsored".
A maintenance routine that covers both
Monthly, for SEO:
- Run a site crawl and fix internal links that return 404 or redirect chains.
- Check Search Console's Pages report for new "Not found (404)" entries that have internal links pointing to them.
- Fix or remove outbound links on your top 20 pages.
Daily or weekly, for income:
- Check every Amazon link for a tag that is present, yours, and in the right place.
- Check every product's stock and status.
- Replace products that have been gone for more than a week, starting with your busiest pages.
The monthly list is a job for an SEO crawler. The daily list needs Amazon's data, which is what Affiliwatch was built to do.
Questions people ask
Will a few broken links get my site penalised?
Are out-of-stock Amazon products broken links?
Should affiliate links be nofollow or sponsored?
rel="sponsored" on affiliate links. rel="nofollow" is also accepted. See rel="sponsored" for affiliate links.How often should I check for broken links?
Sources
Checked on November 17, 2026. Amazon changes its terms from time to time; the linked pages are the final word.